Students matriculating to Texas medical schools sure have a lot to look forward to this coming year. How will Baylor College of Medicine proceed with a new president? How will the University of Texas Medical Branch (UTMB) Galveston continue the recovery process post-Hurricane-Ike? And now, how will the University of Texas Southwestern (UTSW) Dallas students react to a modified grading system?

One of my UTSW-bound friends was courteous enough to send me an e-mail he received regarding the details of this change:

On February 2, 2009, the Faculty Council of UT Southwestern Medical Center unanimously adopted a new grading system for the medical school after several months of study and input from both faculty and students.  Both students and faculty alike agreed that the medical school grading system must find a balance between providing meaningful information for residency program applications and the inevitable stress inherent in any grading system.

The new grading system will be effective beginning in July 2009 as is as follows:

The first half of the first year will be Pass/Fail.  Students will be provided feedback about performance on examinations so that each student can be aware of how well he/she is mastering the material, but the final grade will be either Pass or Fail.  This change will allow students to make the transition into the new environment of medical school more gracefully.

Beginning with the second half of the first year and continuing through the clinical rotations of the third year, students will be graded using a letter grade system (A, B+, B, C, & F).  The numeric cutoffs for grades will be publicized at the beginning of each course.  Having grades awarded in this manner rather than a “normative” basis (grading curve) should eliminate any perception among students that they are competing with each other for grades.  This change should encourage students to focus on the mastery of material and the collegiality essential in the care of patients.

The fourth year will continue to be graded on a Pass/Fail system.

12 Comments

  1. changing the grading system does not matter. you will be ranked no matter what.

  2. Hey Rishi wassup! I just read your blog, and I was wondering which school my big sister should go to! She lives in Dallas and really likes it here but she also got into Baylor and heard it was great. Can I ask you some questions?
    1. How would you describe the average BCM student? like how are their personalities and how old are they?
    2. Where would be the best place to live in Houston? and for those of you in Dallas would you recommend living in Uptown or the Medical district?
    3. Is it true that Baylor has block exams while UTSW has more frequent smaller exams?
    4. What is there to do for fun in Houston vs. Dallas for when I come visit?
    BLOG you later!!

    P.S. i’m eleven and three quarters

    • Your sister is lucky to have such a concerned younger sibling. 🙂 I haven’t started at BCM yet, so I can’t provide many details about the school, but I’ll try my best.

      1.) I’ve heard people talk about this a lot, but honestly, it’s irrelevant to me. Whichever medical school you visit, you’re going to find all sorts of people in the class – the laid back people, the “gunners”, the witty individuals, the good friends, etc. It’s up to you to find your own niche in such a diverse classroom of intelligent peers. I’ve seen this same trend at BCM. As for age, I had to consult a book, but a few years ago the average age was 24 at BCM.

      2.) Most BCM students live in either the Lanesborough or the Greenbriar apartment complexes. They’re really close to school and on the light rail for easy transportation. Don’t know much about UTSW’s lodging choices.

      3.) I do know that BCM has block exams, but I’m not quite sure about UTSW.

      4.) Now this is a question I can answer. Aside from the horrible weather and traffic, Houston has some amazing amenities… especially close to BCM. Rice Village and the Museum District are two hot spots for students to kick back. The Galleria is also pretty close for the shopping enthusiasts. If your sister is a sports fan, the Houston sports arenas (Rockets, Texans, Astros, etc.) are pretty closeby too. I could literally go on and on with each of the aforementioned venues.

      • Thank you for your very insightful response. As a concerned family of the future medical student we have found this blog to be invaluable having answered must of our questions on UTSW s BCM

        Best wishes

        Guju Dad, M.D.

        • If you haven’t already, please be sure to check out this post. It’s a much more in-depth comparison of Baylor Med and UT Southwestern. 🙂

          • Watch this end up being a Guju hookup. “We first met through my blog”. Romance in 2009 these days. LOL. j.k.

      • Thank you

        We have been looking at apartments around utsw and really liked the Jefferson At North End, however on review of the apartments on line we are getting mixed reviews making it difficult to decide what would b the best and safest for a single female medical student. If you have any suggestions and recommendations it would be much appreciated

        Concerned Dad

  3. I think from a grading policy standpoint: This change will probably bring a LOT more students towards the UTSW side and I do think it is a step in the right direction with making the first semester strict Pass/Fail and numeric cutoffs at the beginning just like Baylor. With respect to curving grades in the basic sciences at UTSW, there are only 2 courses that I remember that were curved: Biochemistry and Genetics and in general you were helped by the curve, not hurt by it.

    First semester courses at UTSW are Anatomy, Biochemistry, Genetics, and Embryology. So for incoming students I would say they will definitely like the change as those courses are memorization intensive courses.

    Afterwards though, whether it is A/B+/B/C/F or Honors/High Pass/Pass/Marginal Pass/Fail or Jacket/Wallet/Coat/Pants/Shirt, it’s the same stratification over 5 intervals, it’s the alphabet vs. catchy labels. For naive medical students, the terms “Pass” and “High Pass” tends to give a greater sense of security (although a false sense of security) vs. getting a “C” makes someone feel worse. So with respect to grading scales Baylor and UTSW are equivalent. You call it “Honors”, and I call it an “A”. I liked the letter grade system, but I’m also very biased as I made an “A” in every basic science course I took. I would probably feel differently if I didn’t make all As.

    For the purposes of true decrease in “stress” level and to decrease “competitive” feelings btw students (w/regards to not wanting other students to get an edge – hence not wanting to form study groups, hiding old tests or notes, not wanting to share study aids), the only grading interval that truly achieves this is strict Pass/Fail as is done at these institutions – many of which are top notch as well: http://services.aamc.org/currdir/section1/grading1.cfm (Select “Required Basic Sciences” and “2 intervals”)

    The real reason for a more extended grading interval is for AOA selection. If, for example, we were to go to a strict Pass/Fail only system, the only thing AOA could stratify people on are USMLE Step 1 board scores (something I don’t mind at all actually, as it is a standardized exam and everyone is measured along a standardized yardstick). However, the hooting and hollering would be from students who did very well academically on professor-produced exams through 2 years, but did not do well on USMLE Step 1 a one day exam (those two are not necessarily equivalent as the emphasis both on material of what the professor thinks is important vs. what the USMLE test writers thinks is important AS WELL AS rote memorization vs. concept/critical thinking are very different).

    There are students with stellar preclinical grades who had lackluster or average board scores. There are those with average or ordinary preclinical grades who had stellar board scores.

    I know Baylor College of Medicine used to be, until very recently, strict Pass/Fail in the first year entirely and used H/HP/P/MP/F for the second year. I am very curious as to why that was changed. I highly doubt it had anything to do with straggling board scores or bad match lists or residency program director complaints. More likely it had to do with AOA selection as in reality when it comes to residency programs, they could give a two shits about your actual preclinical grades. It’s a lot easier to tell someone they missed getting into AOA marginally because they had a “High Pass” in Gross Anatomy, then not having ANY justification, no matter how ridiculous.

    At any medical school, my personal opinion is I don’t think the grading system affects how much medical students study. I do think, however, it DOES affect as to WHAT medical students will study. For example, when a strict Pass/Fail system is instituted, students can really learn to master the information well and more importantly well for boards. However, any other system in which you have a variation of that like at UTSW or Baylor, you don’t really learn what you desire, you learn what the PROFESSOR wants you to know and HOW they want you to know it.

    For example, in Pathology, the required textbook and the “Bible” of Pathology is usually Robbins Pathologic Basis of Disease, which if you actually read it is a very well written text. However, we knew better than to actually read the textbook as we knew the professors really did not test from there, but from their own syllabus notes/powerpoints.

    Now if UTSW was strict Pass/Fail would I have comprehensively read Robbins? Of course! After all, there is no question I will be able to Pass the course, that’s not something I have to worry about. Thus, I can try to absorb as much knowledge and learn it the way I’m SUPPOSED to learn it rather than from a professor-made syllabus packet which may have extraneous info, may skip diseases, or not include all information that is in Robbins, such as seeing the connections through Pathophysiology. I know people that started studying from Robbins but would fail a professor-generated exam, and thus would have to go back to studying syllabus notes/powerpoints like the rest of us.

    With the system of A/B+/B/C/F or H/HP/P/MP/F am I likely to read Robbins if the professor doesn’t really cover things they are supposed to in the chapter? Of course not. We are likely to do the study formula that brings the biggest dividends esp. in the short term, in which case the grade being one of them, so if a disease is not covered in the lecture notes, but is in Robbins, naturally I would skip it, and say oh well, as it wouldn’t help me get a question right on the exam coming up and I would be right. However, USMLE Step 1 is not a professor-biased exam, and you are expected to be able to answer questions not based on how a lecturer presented it, but based on what you SHOULD have learned.

    One nice thing about UTSW is we take the NBME subject exams for the basic science in MS-2, which is actually written by the USMLE test writers. Thus, I am able to not only study for professor exams but also study well for a standardized exam and see how well I mastered it based on NBME/USMLE standards. I think the only NBME subject Exam that Baylor students take is the Comprehensive Basic Science Examination in order to promote: http://www.nbme.org/programs-services/medical-schools/subject-examinations/index.html

    • Thank you so much for the references and detailed explanation!! Honestly, before reading your comment, I had very little knowledge regarding “medical school grading”, so I really appreciate it! Perhaps you have some pointers for students who want to emulate your high academic standards. 😉

  4. I’m indifferent about grading systems. I understand that the point of pass/fail is to help ease incoming medical students into the environment, and for that, I think UTSW did something great. 🙂 However, at this point, I think medical students are smart and mature enough to realize that they’ll get out what they put in. If they take advantage of the pass/fail grading and intentionally “slack off”, it’ll ultimately catch up with them. After all, bad habits aren’t easy to get rid of. I doubt this will be the case, since UTSW has some top-notch students… but it’s just a thought.

Write A Comment

Pin It